Some people cannot wait to retire; for others it is an inevitable rite of passage to a precarious future. And while Switzerland is viewed as a good place to grow old, many elderly people also suffer from exclusion, poverty and injustice.
Europe, the “old continent”, is getting older. The European Union declared 2012 ‚European Year For Active Ageing and Solidarity between Generations‘. Its goal is „to raise awareness of the contribution that older people make to society“ and „create better opportunities for active ageing and strengthening solidarity between generations“.
At a recent national conference organised by Pro Senectute – the biggest Swiss organisation supporting the elderly – entitled “The path to successful ageing”, specialists underlined the urgent need to create or improve ways of ensuring that the ‘golden years’ actually mean that in a rich and modern country like Switzerland.
Addressing conference delegates, Silke van Dyke, a sociologist from the Friedrich Schiller University in Jena, Germany, questioned whether pensioners should be encouraged to be more active.
At the same time she warned: „The social utility of the elderly – in other words their activities – should not be the decisive criteria for a successful old age.“
Ageing on your own terms
Set against a backdrop of extreme cost-cutting and the slow dismantling of social benefits, van Dyke said it was not the behaviour – supposedly passive – of elderly people that was problematic, but their relationships within society.
And she rejected the ‘‘win-win’ notion that associates productive old age with social recognition, defended by politicians and scientists.
Criticising those who are active at all costs doesn’t mean advocating passive old age either. Rather it is „a plea for the creation of suitable conditions to determine how each individual wants to handle their life during retirement”, van Dyke said.
„There are different ways of ageing well and they don’t all involve activity. The important thing is that everyone ages at their own pace and in their own way,“ Pro Senectute director Alain Huber told swissinfo.ch. „The important thing is that everyone can be happy as they get older.“
The key to ‘ageing well’
Huber said that the right conditions for ageing well in Switzerland exist now.
“But we must be careful. We know that demographic changes are coming,” he warned. “Many people lack sufficient resources and are on the poverty line despite additional benefits.”
Pasqualina Perrig-Chiello, a professor of psychology at Bern University, said indicators such as physical health, life expectancy or personal satisfaction show that the quality of life of older people has improved considerably in recent decades.
„Old age has been democratised,“ said Perrig-Chiello, adding that „inequalities remain essentially linked to individual conditions. There are still vulnerable groups who lack economic, social and physical resources.“
According to Perrig-Chiello, one way of making old age even more democratic would be a participatory process to help focus the debate on the disparity of resources rather than on the differences between ages and generations.
“The injustices experienced by elderly people occur within the same generation and not between generations,“ theologian Béatrice Bowald of the Swiss National Commission for Justice and Peace told swissinfo.ch.
Bowald said the commission had proposed introducing a federal tax on inheritances which would be directed into the Swiss pension scheme as a way of bridging the gaps between the rich and poor amongst the elderly, and of ensuring a long-term system of providing for the older generation.
“Only a few people are extremely wealthy and there are many who have nothing,“ Bowald said. „This tax would allow for greater justice.“
Wealth and poverty
Monica Budowski, a sociologist at Fribourg University, said within families, solidarity between generations was not at risk thanks to the transfer of knowledge, contacts, forms of behaviour and property. However, outside the family nucleus, the situation was quite different, she said.
„If solidarity existed beyond the family circle, generations would have the same opportunities regardless of how wealthy the family was,” Budowski said.
„Social inequalities persist given the limited financial resources within the family circle. [Financial] inequalities increase with age and reach a peak between 55 to 70 years old.”
Van Dyke regretted that current debate tended to get bogged down over the so-called generation gap, and lose sight of the main point that „greater social inequalities occur when people get old”.
Images of happy retired people, rejuvenated by miraculous, expensive treatments participating in sporting, social and cultural events stand in stark contrast to those of elderly people whose poor education condemns them to menial work and ultimately a shorter life.
But that, said van Dyke, “is one of the great taboos of current discussions about old age and ageing”.
Between three and four per cent of pensioners suffer from poverty, despite receiving additional state benefits.
About 12% of the elderly need additional services and would suffer from poverty without receiving benefits.
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) estimates that 18% of the Swiss population suffers from poverty before receiving benefits.
Amongst people aged over 60 there is greater inequality in income and wealth.
While one in seven retired couples has a fortune of more than SFr1 million ($1.03 million), about one in ten has less than SFr10,000.
Source: Pro Senectute